Authorship policy

Authorship is earned, never sold.

Every InsightMed paper follows the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) criteria. Joining a project gives you a role. Doing that role well earns your authorship.

Effective 19 November 2026

Our rule: Payment never buys a name on a paper.

The four ICMJE criteria

Every named author must meet all four:

  • A substantial contribution to the design, data acquisition, analysis or interpretation of the work.
  • Drafting the work or revising it critically for important content.
  • Final approval of the version to be submitted.
  • Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work.

How each role meets them

  • Screening and data extraction: blind dual review on Rayyan and extraction checked by a second reviewer.
  • Risk of bias: study quality assessed with the right tool, such as ROB 2, ROBINS I, NOS or QUADAS 2.
  • Writing: drafting an assigned manuscript section and revising it after review.
  • Final approval and accountability: reading and approving the final manuscript and signing the authorship confirmation.

How author order is decided

Author order follows ICMJE contribution. Authors who contribute most to the design, analysis and writing are placed first. The project lead proposes the order based on tracked contributions, and every author confirms it before submission.

Missed deadlines

Each role has clear deadlines. If you miss 3 deadlines without a reason agreed with your project lead, you move from the author list to the acknowledgements.

Contributors who do not qualify

People who help but do not meet all four criteria are named in the acknowledgements, with their agreement.

Use of AI tools

AI tools cannot be authors. Any use of AI in a manuscript is disclosed as the target journal requires, and authors remain responsible for every word and number.

Disputes

Raise any authorship concern with your project lead first, then with the founder. We resolve disputes using ICMJE and COPE guidance, and any change to the author list after submission goes through the journal's own process with every author's agreement.

Contact

Questions about authorship: insight.med78@gmail.com.