Free resource

The pre-submission checklist. 69 checks before you press submit.

A two-page PDF built from the problems we see most often in desk rejections and first-round reviews. Covers journal fit, authorship, methods, numbers, references and every statement journals ask for.

We send the PDF to you directly, usually within a few hours. No spam, and you can ask us to remove your number at any time.

Section 1 · 5 checks

Journal fit

For example: The journal is indexed in PubMed/MEDLINE or Scopus and is not on a predatory list.

Section 2 · 7 checks

Title page and authorship

For example: Every author meets all four ICMJE authorship criteria.

Section 3 · 6 checks

Abstract

For example: Every number matches the Results section exactly.

Section 4 · 4 checks

Introduction

For example: Cites the most recent existing reviews on the same question.

Section 5 · 11 checks

Methods

For example: Full search strategy for at least one database is in the supplement.

Section 6 · 7 checks

Results and numbers

For example: Flow diagram numbers add up at every step.

Section 7 · 6 checks

Tables and figures

For example: Each one can be understood without reading the text.

Section 8 · 5 checks

Discussion

For example: Limitations are honest and specific, not generic.

Section 9 · 6 checks

References

For example: Every reference is real and you have opened it yourself.

Section 10 · 8 checks

Statements and files

For example: AI use disclosed in line with the journal's policy.

Section 11 · 4 checks

Final read

For example: All co-authors approved this final version in writing.

Want us to check it for you?

Pre-submission manuscript audit

We run every one of these checks on your manuscript, recalculate the numbers and verify every reference, then send you a written report of what to fix. See the audit →