Endoscopic vs conventional discectomy for lumbar disc herniation
The question
Open discectomy is the standard operation for lumbar disc herniation, and minimally invasive endoscopic techniques have become an alternative. The team asked whether endoscopic discectomy performs as well as conventional techniques for pain, function, safety and recovery.
What the team did
The team searched PubMed, Scopus, the Cochrane Library and Web of Science from inception until January 2025. They included 13 randomised controlled trials and one retrospective comparative study, and pooled back pain, leg pain, disability (ODI), complications, reoperation and hospital stay.
What they found
Endoscopic discectomy was comparable to conventional techniques for back pain, leg pain, disability, complications and reoperation. It was associated with a shorter hospital stay (standardised mean difference −2.40, 95% CI −4.31 to −0.49), although heterogeneity for that outcome was substantial (I² = 97%). The authors conclude the choice of technique should be individualised.
The team
Ten authors from several countries worked on the project, including Abdulaziz Sobhi, now a medical intern.
Working on our systematic review and meta-analysis on lumbar disc herniation was a great learning experience for me. It gave me a better understanding of how medical research works, from reviewing studies to interpreting findings, and helped me develop my research and scientific writing skills. Most importantly, it gave me more confidence to get involved in future research projects.