How to Respond to Reviewer Comments on a Medical Paper
Read the decision the right way
A "major revision" decision means the editor wants to publish your paper if you fix the problems. Read all comments once, wait a day, then sort them into three groups: quick fixes (wording, typos, references), substantive changes (new analyses, extra limitations) and points you may need to discuss with the editor.
Structure of a response letter
- Short cover note to the editor. Thank them, summarise the main changes in three or four lines, and confirm all authors approved the revision.
- Each reviewer in turn. Copy each comment word for word, number it (Reviewer 1, Comment 1), then write your response directly under it.
- Every response has three parts: a thank you or acknowledgement, what you did, and where it now appears (page and line numbers, plus the quoted new text).
- A marked version of the manuscript with tracked changes or highlighting, plus a clean version, as the journal requests.
A template you can copy
Reviewer 1, Comment 3: "The authors do not explain the high heterogeneity in the primary outcome."
Response: Thank you for this helpful point. We have added a leave one out sensitivity analysis and a subgroup analysis by study design. Heterogeneity fell from I² 78% to 41% when the two retrospective studies were removed. We describe this in the Results (page 9, lines 210 to 218) and discuss it as a limitation (page 14, lines 330 to 336). New text: "When the two retrospective cohorts were excluded, heterogeneity decreased substantially..."
How to disagree politely
You do not have to make every change. When a request is wrong or outside the scope of the paper, say so respectfully and give a reason the editor can accept:
- Acknowledge the point: "We agree this is an important question."
- Give the reason with evidence: data, a reference or a limit of the design.
- Offer a middle path where you can, such as a sentence in the limitations.
Avoid words like "the reviewer is mistaken". Write as if the editor is reading over your shoulder, because they are.
Mistakes that cause rejection after revision
- Skipping or merging comments so some go unanswered.
- Saying "we have revised the manuscript" without showing where.
- Changing numbers in the text but not in tables, figures and abstract.
- Adding new analyses without updating the methods section and, for systematic reviews, the PROSPERO record.
- Missing the resubmission deadline. Ask the editor for an extension early if you need one.
Sources
Based on common editorial guidance from medical journals and the InsightMed team's experience revising systematic reviews and meta-analyses.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a response letter be?
As long as it needs to be to answer every comment clearly. Short answers to small points, full detail with quoted text for major ones.
Should I thank the reviewers?
Yes. A brief, genuine thank you at the start of each reviewer section and for helpful points is standard.
Can I ask the editor about a comment I do not understand?
Yes. A short, polite email to the editorial office asking for clarification is better than guessing.
Do I need to answer comments from the editor too?
Yes. Treat editor comments exactly like reviewer comments and answer each one.
